Follow the dollar
Renew's money to Minnesotans for Justice to First Principles PAC in Nashville, and into the attorney general race.
Follow the dollar.
Here’s the question we left open on Oct. 1. Scroll to follow the route.
It starts in Arlington, Va.
GOPAC Election Fund sent Renew $6,700,000 in 2026, about 69% of Renew’s money this year.
July 21, 2026
Renew sent Minnesotans for Justice $1,225,000. Williamson chairs both.
The same day
Minnesotans for Justice sent $720,000 to First Principles PAC, a political committee based in Nashville, Tennessee.
The next day
First Principles’ October report to the Federal Election Commission fills in the rest. The $720,000 landed in its federal account on July 21. On July 22, that same account paid a Minnesota ad buy: $555,990 to Medium Buying. In September it paid two more: $400,100 to Vaulter on Sept. 8 and $399,140 on Sept. 11. Those payments match First Principles’ Minnesota reports to the dollar. Its Minnesota committee opened 2026 with a cash balance of zero. The $720,000 was the first contribution it received all year, and on July 22 it spent $719,490 of it — $555,990 with Medium Buying of Columbus, Ohio, $150,000 with the Valentine Group and $13,500 with PRIME Media Partners of Arlington, Virginia — every dollar reported as spending against Ellison. The $2,000,000 from the national First Principles PAC did not start arriving until Sept. 8, seven weeks later.
Into the attorney general race
First Principles reported spending $391,096 backing Ron Schutz, the Republican running for attorney general, and $2,296,006 against Keith Ellison. With what Minnesotans for Justice spent on its own, the committees in this chain have put about $5.8 million against Ellison and about $423,000 behind Schutz.
One caution, and it matters.
First Principles’ account holds money from other donors too. Its Minnesota committee took in $2,720,000 this year — $2,000,000 of it from the national First Principles PAC in Nashville, in four payments of $500,000 each on Sept. 8, Sept. 10, Sept. 25 and Oct. 6, and the $720,000 from Minnesotans for Justice. Across the year, Renew’s chain accounts for about a quarter of it. For the ads that ran on July 22, it accounts for all of it.The Washington Sun reported in April that the Lexington Fund, a group linked to conservative legal activist Leonard Leo, gave First Principles nearly $3.3 million in 2025. Federal filings show $7.15 million from the Lexington Fund since January 2025, including $500,000 on July 22, 2026, the same day as the Minnesota ad buy. So we can’t say Renew’s dollars paid for any particular ad. What the filings show is the route.
What voters saw
The name “First Principles PAC.” Not Renew Minnesota, Mitchell Williamson or GOPAC.
For balance: Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC, a DFL-aligned committee, has spent $4,705,862 against Schutz this year. Most of its money this year, $7,650,000, came from another committee, We All Do Better PAC, so it passes through more than one name too. Outside money is flowing on both sides of this race. We looked at how that side is built, too. Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC is funded by the Alliance for a Better Minnesota nonprofit, which gave it $400,000 in cash and $178,424 in staff and operating costs; by We All Do Better PAC; and by the ‘Sota Project. All three list the same St. Paul ZIP code as the committee. We All Do Better PAC lists one person, Denise Cardinal, as both its chair and its treasurer. So we checked that side’s committees the same way we checked this one: every committee and fund registered with the Campaign Finance Board, 902 of them, active and terminated.
Two things we had taken for marks of this network turned out to be ordinary. Cardinal is chair and treasurer of three committees of her own that are open now: WIN Minnesota PAC, We All Do Better PAC and Minnesota Progress. She is also treasurer of a federal super PAC, WIN Minnesota Federal PAC. And the money behind her committees is no more local than Renew’s: We All Do Better raised $7,271,000 this year and 78.9 percent of it came from outside Minnesota, against 75.7 percent of the $8,237,892 Renew took in. More than half of it, $3,936,000, came from a single group in Washington — the Democratic Attorneys General Association’s People’s Lawyer Project. Her newest committee, Minnesota Progress, registered Aug. 17, took 98 percent of its $1,409,100 from outside the state. Both sides are built on committee stacks. Both run on national money. Anyone who tells you otherwise has looked at one side.

Four things are not the same.
The pace. Cardinal opened six state committees over seventeen years and has never had more than three open at once. Williamson opened seven in thirty-one months, and six are open now. A seventh Williamson committee, MN Business & Labor Coalition, ran from March 2024 to January 2025, and the business council’s 2024 IRS filing lists that one as a committee it controls too.
The circle. Moving money between your own committees is legal, and it is not new. Two committees Cardinal ran sent each other $2,752,600 in 2020 and 2022, and in 2020 they sent $2,220,500 to the federal super PAC she is treasurer of. But nothing on her side this year comes close. Through Oct. 19, Williamson moved $4,782,045 out of Renew in 32 transfers, every one into a committee where he is also the chair and the treasurer, $4,362,045 of it to Minnesotans for Justice. In the next four days he moved $555,000 more. That is $5,337,045 in 36 transfers. Fifty-eight percent of everything Renew took in this year through Oct. 19, $8,237,892, went straight back out to his own committees. This year, Cardinal’s committees moved $685,000 between themselves, in one transfer: WIN Minnesota PAC to We All Do Better PAC on Oct. 21. Add the nonprofit each of them signs for, and the gap holds. WIN Minnesota gave Cardinal’s committees $612,189 this year, for a total of $1,297,189. The business council gave Renew $2,730,000, for a total of $8,067,045 on Williamson’s side, more than six times as much.
Where the money lands. Williamson’s money stays with Williamson. Minnesotans for Justice, which has taken every dollar it has from Renew, has spent $3,473,870 against Ellison. Cardinal’s committees hand theirs off. We All Do Better sent $8,485,000 this year, through Oct. 22, to Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC, which has its own chair and its own treasurer and does the spending.
The nonprofit behind it. Each side has a nonprofit run by the person who runs its committees. WIN Minnesota, where Cardinal is executive director, has given her committees $612,189 this year. On its July statement it named where its $450,000 came from: Strategic Victory Fund of Raleigh, N.C., a group rather than a person, but a name. The business council has given Renew $2,730,000 this year, $1.1 million of it from Oct. 20 to 23. On its Oct. 6 statement, signed by Williamson as the council’s officer, every dollar is listed as coming from sources “not required to be itemized.” It names no one. And only one of these nonprofits tells the IRS that it controls the committee it funds: the business council reports that it is Renew’s direct controlling entity, and marks Renew a controlled entity under section 512(b)(13), in both 2023 and 2024. WIN Minnesota’s 2024 filing reports no related organizations. Alliance for a Better Minnesota names no controlling entity for any of its affiliates.

Separately, we found no DFL counterpart to a tax-exempt charity that gave a news site $420,000 and whose board includes this year’s Republican candidate for attorney general. We checked that too. Alliance for a Better Minnesota runs its own 501(c)(3), the Education Fund, at the same St. Paul address as the committee. Its IRS filings report two grants of more than $5,000 from 2020 through 2024: $31,000 to Navigate MN in 2020 and $286,200 to North Star Prosperity, a 501(c)(4), in 2021, both listed as voter education. It reported no grants in 2023 or 2024. Its annual revenue ran between $318,000 and $728,000. It funds no news outlet. One limit: we went through the DFL side’s committee registrations, its receipts and its charity’s grant filings, not every nonprofit in Minnesota politics. Where we looked, we printed what we found.
Follow his record and you keep landing in the same place.
Ron Schutz wants to be Minnesota’s top law enforcement officer. The same place is the Center of the American Experiment, the conservative think tank based in Minnetonka.
Board member, former chair
A CAE director, per its 2025 IRS filing. On his 2025 candidate survey: “the former chair and a current board member” of CAE.
CAE’s recordings
The recordings his campaign website cites on fraud are from a December 2021 meeting that KSTP reported CAE first made public, according to KSTP. On Sept. 22, a CAE piece on his race never told readers he sits on its board.
The circle closes
Ron Eibensteiner chairs CAE. He was treasurer of the Minnesota Private Business Council, the group that controls Renew, in 2023 and 2024, according to its IRS filings. He gave Schutz’s campaign $2,500, the legal maximum.
The full story on Ron Schutz
This is a preview. Our next piece follows the candidate’s own record, his foundation’s giving and the network around his campaign, in full.
A note on names: Jim Schultz, with an l, ran for attorney general in 2022 and now leads the business council. Ron Schutz, no l, is this year’s candidate.

