The Politics ChicksFollow the MN Money
Follow the MN Money · Part 2 · Nov. 2, 2026

The Money Behind the Political Negativity MarketWho Wore Out Your Mute Button, Filled Your Recycling Bin and Blew Up Your Phone

Both sides wanted your attention. One paid more than twice as much to get it.

If you live in a contested state Senate district, you’ve probably heard from some of these committees this fall. Five names. It sounds like a crowd.

Renew MinnesotaMinnesotans for JusticeCommon Sense MinnesotaEmpower MinnesotaBuild MinnesotaAnd a sixth: Main Street Minnesota PAC
It’s one man.All six list the same chair and treasurer with the Minnesota Campaign Finance Board: Mitchell Williamson.

This site follows money through public records. It does not allege that anyone broke a law. Items marked Oct. 1 come from our first investigation; New is from this one.

01 · Where we left off Oct. 1, updated

Three of every four dollars came from Virginia.

$0
from GOPAC Election Fund in Arlington, Va., to Renew Minnesota in six 2026 checks
0%
of everything Renew raised in 2026

On Oct. 1, we published “Gigantic Kettle Calls Little Pot Black.” It showed that GOPAC, a national group built in 1978 to grow a Republican “farm team” in the statehouses, was bankrolling Renew Minnesota.

We ended that story with a list of questions the filings couldn’t answer yet. One of them was what a Nashville committee did with $720,000 of Renew’s money.

Now we know. And the answer led somewhere bigger than one committee.

Graphic: GOPAC gave under three names to four Minnesota committees
What GOPAC put into Minnesota in 2026, under three different names.
02 · One man, six committees New

The same chair. The same treasurer.

Every one of those committees, and a sixth, Main Street Minnesota PAC, which has raised nothing, lists the same chair and the same treasurer with the Minnesota Campaign Finance Board: Mitchell Williamson. His own X bio says it plainly: “Chair @RenewMN @MinnForJustice.”

Mitchell Williamson's X bio: Minnesotan | Chair @RenewMN @MinnForJustice
His X bio, captured Oct. 16, 2026.

Chair and treasurer of Renew Minnesota

Since July 2023.

Lobbyist for the group that controls Renew

Director of operations at the Minnesota Private Business Council since May 2023, and its registered lobbyist (#5592). The council controls Renew, according to its own IRS filing (Schedule R), and has given it $0 through Oct. 19, 2026. The same filings, for 2023 and 2024, name him as the person who possesses the council’s books and records.

Jim Schultz’s 2022 political director

The attorney general campaign paid him $42,951. Schultz now runs the business council.

Senate Victory Fund field staff

The Minnesota Senate Republicans’ caucus committee, in 2020.

The registered lobbyist for the group that controls Renew is also the person who signs Renew’s checks.

And Renew writes a lot of checks to his other committees.

Minnesotans for Justice
$4,362,045
Common Sense MN
$165,500
Build Minnesota
$141,000
Empower Minnesota
$113,500

Every dollar Empower has ever reported came from Renew. Renew and Empower both report paying the same texting firm, Nuntius Borealis; Renew also pays for the ad placement, mail and Facebook ads. A voter gets texts from four different names. The money behind all four traces back to one committee and one chair.

Minnesota law lets one person be both chair and treasurer of a committee. Nothing here breaks that rule. What it shows is how much control sits with one person, behind names built to sound like a movement.
Graphic: One man, six committees
Different names on the ads. The same chair and treasurer on every current filing — and he is the registered lobbyist for the business council that controls Renew.
Graphic: The money flow
$6,075,000 from Arlington into Renew, $4,362,045 from Renew into another committee the same man chairs, and on into the attorney general race.
03 · What one man’s committees have spent Oct. 1, updated

The volume.

$0
raised by Renew since 2023
$0
spent on Renew’s own ads, mail and texts since 2023
$0
reported by Minnesotans for Justice against Attorney General Keith Ellison

Renew’s biggest 2026 Senate targets

Sen. Grant Hauschild
$660,160
Sen. Aric Putnam
$557,737
Kristy Janigo
$536,347
Sen. Rob Kupec
$453,490
Sen. Judy Seeberger
$372,719

Janigo is No. 3. Renew has spent about three and a half times as much attacking her as backing her opponent, Brady Hoag.

Figures through Oct. 19, 2026, from Minnesota Campaign Finance Board reports, the end of the last reports filed before the election.

Graphic: Who Renew spent against
Renew spent $536,347 against Kristy Janigo and $152,732 backing her opponent — about three and a half times as much to attack as to support.
Renew Minnesota mailer against Kristy Janigo
A Renew mailer against Janigo, October 2026. Recipient details removed.
Graphic: One man’s committees, by the numbers
$11.1 million raised since 2023. $4.78 million of it passed in 2026 to four other committees the same man chairs.
09 · Update: what Renew did when our first article dropped New

They didn’t dispute the facts. They went after Kristy Janigo, through us.

Our Oct. 1 piece went up at 9:06 a.m. Renew had our questions at least a day earlier and declined to comment. Here’s what came back.

9:06 a.m.

We publish the GOPAC money.

“Gigantic Kettle Calls Little Pot Black.”

By 4:42 p.m.

Renew has a new page on its website.

By about 6 p.m.

Posts on Facebook and X.

The graphic read: “KRISTY JANIGO EMBRACES POLITICAL VIOLENCE AND CALLS FOR REPUBLICANS TO DIE!” She said no such thing.

Renew Minnesota X post, Oct. 1, 2026
By 6:15 p.m.

A text blast to voters.

It invoked the assassination of Melissa Hortman and her husband.

Renew Minnesota text message, Oct. 1, 2026
Oct. 6

Alpha News runs its story, crediting Renew.

Its headline tied a second guest to the posts: “Democrats Peggy Flanagan and Kristy Janigo appeared on podcast that issued vile posts.” Flanagan is running for U.S. Senate; Renew’s attacks hadn’t named her. Alpha asked both Flanagan and Janigo about us. It never contacted us. It pinned the post to the top of its X account for part of Oct. 7. It has passed 38,000 views. Commenters under Alpha’s posts called on the FBI, the Secret Service, the Department of Homeland Security and the Justice Department to act against us, and pushed to get Monica fired from a teaching job she has already retired from.

Oct. 13

The Star Tribune repeats the posts, crediting Alpha News.

A story on podcast politics in the U.S. Senate race quoted the same posts. It asked Flanagan’s campaign to respond to the posts. It never contacted us, and it didn’t mention Renew. We stayed silent until after the election, because anything we said was being used against candidates. Read it ↗

Oct. 15

Renew’s video calls us “extremists who advocate for violence and political assassinations.”

The same day, Williamson told Sen. Aric Putnam “17 times in one day might not be enough.”

Oct. 20

“Dangerous” runs as a paid YouTube ad against Janigo.

In Maple Grove-area ZIP codes, built out of the same posts. By Nov. 2 it had passed 305,000 views — zero likes and zero comments — on a channel with 113 subscribers.

Renew’s ads carry the line, required by law, that no candidate is responsible for them. Then they held a candidate responsible for us.

We’re not going to pretend our old posts didn’t exist. We wrote them and we own them. But Kristy Janigo didn’t write a word of them.

About the posts

Through 2025, it became clearer to us that this administration was trampling on people’s rights. Then, from December 2025 into February 2026, Operation Metro Surge brought thousands of federal immigration agents into the Twin Cities, in what the Department of Homeland Security called the largest immigration enforcement operation it had ever carried out. We watched it happen in our own community: neighbors, including children, detained, schools and businesses shaken, and two U.S. citizens, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, killed by federal agents. We watched those shootings over and over.

Most frightening of all: Three of the six children we have between us had their own encounters with ICE, two of them at gunpoint.

Living through that took a real toll. We were afraid for our kids, our neighbors and our country. We lived with that for months, and it shaped what we wrote. None of it was a call for violence. It was the anger and dark, sardonic humor people reach for when they feel powerless against the people hurting them.

We weren’t the only Minnesotans posting in anger that winter. Renew went looking for ours only when it became convenient. Because here’s the thing: none of Renew’s ads tell voters where three-quarters of its money came from this year. The information is public, but only for anyone willing to dig through thousands of pages of state campaign finance reports, IRS returns and federal election filings to connect it. We did exactly that. When we published our findings, Renew answered the same day, not with a rebuttal, but with our old posts under a candidate’s name. That’s context, not an excuse.

And we voluntarily took the posts down because they aren’t who we want to be.

But a committee that won’t dispute the facts, and goes after the messenger instead, is telling you everything you need to know about the facts.

Watch: Quiet, Not Idle

Graphic: The playbook: the same labels, over and over
“Dangerous.” “Con Artist.” “Airhead.” The same labels, over and over.
Graphic: “It will get worse”
A senator said his students saw Renew’s ad seventeen times in one day. Renew’s chair replied that seventeen might not be enough.
08 · Same checks, different names Oct. 1, updated

The same donors, writing checks under different names.

On Oct. 1 we laid out how the Senate Victory Fund, the Senate Republicans’ own caucus committee, is spending in these races. What we didn’t show then is who it shares with Renew.

DonorTo Renew, 2023–26To the Senate Victory Fund, 2025–26
Robert Ulrich, retired Target CEO, Edina$190,000
$175,000
Tom Rosen, owner of Rosen’s Diversified, Fairmont$290,000
$100,000
Jerry Papenfuss, Winona$65,000
$5,000

Ulrich has given the caucus fund $725,000 since 2015. Ron Schutz, the Republican candidate for attorney general, has given it $1,500 over the past two years. Williamson was on its payroll in 2020. Renew and the caucus fund have both reported spending this year to help the same 10 Republican Senate candidates, Brady Hoag among them. In SD37, the caucus fund has run Facebook video ads against Janigo since Oct. 6, under the page name “North Star Values.”

The filings show no money moving directly between Renew and the Senate Victory Fund. Shared donors, a past job and shared candidates do not mean one committee directs the other. But for a voter in Maple Grove trying to figure out who is paying to tell them about Kristy Janigo, the answer keeps coming back to many of the same people.
Oct. 1, updated

New Fund LLC

GOPAC and the Republican State Leadership Committee funded another Minnesota committee, too. New Fund LLC registered in September 2024 and raised $1,998,000, nearly all of it from Oct. 10 to Nov. 4, including $1.1 million from the RSLC and $350,000 from GOPAC Election Fund the day before the election.

That fall it spent in 30 Minnesota House races, every one of them also a Renew race, and in three of them, both groups reported payments to the same ad firm, Arena, on the same days. New Fund has a different chair and treasurer; Williamson isn’t on its paperwork. This fall it is mailing for Brady Hoag in SD37 and has reported $86,582 on his race. Its only funder in 2026 is GOPAC Inc., which gave it $1,000,000 on Oct. 2 and another $1,200,000 on Oct. 22 — $2,200,000 in all.

New Fund LLC mailer for Brady Hoag
New Fund’s mailer for Brady Hoag, October 2026. Recipient details removed.
Graphic: outside money came after Kristy Janigo nearly 10 to 1
Every committee that reported independent spending on the race: $1,141,308 against her, $117,633 for her. First Amendment LLC, which lists no donors, accounts for $180,838.
Graphic: The same donors, writing checks under different names
Renew’s three biggest individual donors gave $280,000 to the Senate GOP caucus fund that also spent against Janigo.
06 · The outlet New

What Alpha News didn’t tell its readers.

On Oct. 6, Alpha News ran a story about The Politics Chicks. It said our posts were “first uncovered by Renew Minnesota, a GOP-aligned political action committee.” Tap each card.

The stories line up with Renew’s.

We found three Alpha stories built on Renew material: a residency claim against Sarah Kruger, a DFL legislative candidate in Winona, in 2024, the story about us on Oct. 6, and an Oct. 15 story about DFL House candidate Aaron Schweiger that embedded Renew’s own attack post. Two of the three were written by the same reporter, nine days apart.

That reporter’s Oct. 5 story on the Senate District 14 race didn’t mention the $447,854 Renew had spent against Sen. Aric Putnam by then. Alpha’s Sept. 9 story on outside money in Minnesota didn’t mention the $2.875 million Renew had already taken from GOPAC.

Then there’s the loop
Alpha publishes. Renew’s chair amplifies it, sometimes with his own attack line.
Williamson building on Alpha News's Klein story, April 22, 2026
April 22, 2026: on Alpha’s Klein story
Williamson reposts Alpha News's Flanagan story, October 2026
October 2026: reposting Alpha’s Flanagan story
Opinion columns are opinion columns, and a news site can take money from anyone it likes. The issue is disclosure. Alpha’s standards say: “If a report includes adverse information about people or organizations, we do our best to give them the opportunity to respond.” Alpha asked the candidates. It never gave us that chance.
Graphic: What Alpha didn't tell readers
Alpha credited Renew for “uncovering” our posts. It never told readers that Renew’s chair had written for Alpha.
04 · What Nashville did with the money New

Follow the dollar.

Here’s the question we left open on Oct. 1. Scroll to follow the route.

Oct. 1

It starts in Arlington, Va.

GOPAC Election Fund sent Renew $6,075,000 in 2026, about 74% of Renew’s money this year.

July 21, 2026

Renew sent Minnesotans for Justice $1,225,000. Williamson chairs both.

The same day

Minnesotans for Justice sent $720,000 to First Principles PAC, a political committee based in Nashville, Tennessee.

New

The next day

First Principles’ October report to the Federal Election Commission fills in the rest. The $720,000 landed in its federal account on July 21. On July 22, that same account paid a Minnesota ad buy: $555,990 to Medium Buying. In September it paid two more: $400,100 to Vaulter on Sept. 8 and $399,140 on Sept. 11. Those payments match First Principles’ Minnesota reports to the dollar. Its Minnesota committee opened 2026 with a cash balance of zero. The $720,000 was the first contribution it received all year, and on July 22 it spent $719,490 of it — $555,990 with Medium Buying of Columbus, Ohio, $150,000 with the Valentine Group and $13,500 with PRIME Media Partners of Arlington, Virginia — every dollar reported as spending against Ellison. The $2,000,000 from the national First Principles PAC did not start arriving until Sept. 8, seven weeks later.

Into the attorney general race

First Principles reported spending $391,096 backing Ron Schutz, the Republican running for attorney general, and $2,296,006 against Keith Ellison. With what Minnesotans for Justice spent on its own, the committees in this chain have put about $5.8 million against Ellison and about $423,000 behind Schutz.

One caution, and it matters.

First Principles’ account holds money from other donors too. Its Minnesota committee took in $2,720,000 this year — $2,000,000 of it from the national First Principles PAC in Nashville, in four payments of $500,000 each on Sept. 8, Sept. 10, Sept. 25 and Oct. 6, and the $720,000 from Minnesotans for Justice. Across the year, Renew’s chain accounts for about a quarter of it. For the ads that ran on July 22, it accounts for all of it.The Washington Sun reported in April that the Lexington Fund, a group linked to conservative legal activist Leonard Leo, gave First Principles nearly $3.3 million in 2025. Federal filings show $7.15 million from the Lexington Fund since January 2025, including $500,000 on July 22, 2026, the same day as the Minnesota ad buy. So we can’t say Renew’s dollars paid for any particular ad. What the filings show is the route.

What voters saw

The name “First Principles PAC.” Not Renew Minnesota, Mitchell Williamson or GOPAC.

For balance: Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC, a DFL-aligned committee, has spent $4,705,862 against Schutz this year. Most of its money this year, $7,650,000, came from another committee, We All Do Better PAC, so it passes through more than one name too. Outside money is flowing on both sides of this race. We looked at how that side is built, too. Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC is funded by the Alliance for a Better Minnesota nonprofit, which gave it $400,000 in cash and $178,424 in staff and operating costs; by We All Do Better PAC; and by the ‘Sota Project. All three list the same St. Paul ZIP code as the committee. We All Do Better PAC lists one person, Denise Cardinal, as both its chair and its treasurer. So we checked that side’s committees the same way we checked this one: every committee and fund registered with the Campaign Finance Board, 902 of them, active and terminated.

Two things we had taken for marks of this network turned out to be ordinary. Cardinal is chair and treasurer of three committees of her own that are open now: WIN Minnesota PAC, We All Do Better PAC and Minnesota Progress. She is also treasurer of a federal super PAC, WIN Minnesota Federal PAC. And the money behind her committees is no more local than Renew’s: We All Do Better raised $7,271,000 this year and 78.9 percent of it came from outside Minnesota, against 75.7 percent of the $8,237,892 Renew took in. More than half of it, $3,936,000, came from a single group in Washington — the Democratic Attorneys General Association’s People’s Lawyer Project. Her newest committee, Minnesota Progress, registered Aug. 17, took 98 percent of its $1,409,100 from outside the state. Both sides are built on committee stacks. Both run on national money. Anyone who tells you otherwise has looked at one side.

Graphic: both sides take national money; only one sends it to itself
We ran the same check on the DFL side: all 902 committees and funds registered with the Campaign Finance Board, and the Board’s 2026 contribution data. Green marks the figures where that side is higher.

Four things are not the same.

The pace. Cardinal opened six state committees over seventeen years and has never had more than three open at once. Williamson opened seven in thirty-one months, and six are open now. A seventh Williamson committee, MN Business & Labor Coalition, ran from March 2024 to January 2025, and the business council’s 2024 IRS filing lists that one as a committee it controls too.

The circle. Moving money between your own committees is legal, and it is not new. Two committees Cardinal ran sent each other $2,752,600 in 2020 and 2022, and in 2020 they sent $2,220,500 to the federal super PAC she is treasurer of. But nothing on her side this year comes close. Through Oct. 19, Williamson moved $4,782,045 out of Renew in 32 transfers, every one into a committee where he is also the chair and the treasurer, $4,362,045 of it to Minnesotans for Justice. In the next four days he moved $555,000 more. That is $5,337,045 in 36 transfers. Fifty-eight percent of everything Renew took in this year through Oct. 19, $8,237,892, went straight back out to his own committees. This year, Cardinal’s committees moved $685,000 between themselves, in one transfer: WIN Minnesota PAC to We All Do Better PAC on Oct. 21. Add the nonprofit each of them signs for, and the gap holds. WIN Minnesota gave Cardinal’s committees $612,189 this year, for a total of $1,297,189. The business council gave Renew $2,730,000, for a total of $8,067,045 on Williamson’s side, more than six times as much.

Where the money lands. Williamson’s money stays with Williamson. Minnesotans for Justice, which has taken every dollar it has from Renew, has spent $3,473,870 against Ellison. Cardinal’s committees hand theirs off. We All Do Better sent $8,485,000 this year, through Oct. 22, to Alliance for a Better Minnesota State PAC, which has its own chair and its own treasurer and does the spending.

The nonprofit behind it. Each side has a nonprofit run by the person who runs its committees. WIN Minnesota, where Cardinal is executive director, has given her committees $612,189 this year. On its July statement it named where its $450,000 came from: Strategic Victory Fund of Raleigh, N.C., a group rather than a person, but a name. The business council has given Renew $2,730,000 this year, $1.1 million of it from Oct. 20 to 23. On its Oct. 6 statement, signed by Williamson as the council’s officer, every dollar is listed as coming from sources “not required to be itemized.” It names no one. And only one of these nonprofits tells the IRS that it controls the committee it funds: the business council reports that it is Renew’s direct controlling entity, and marks Renew a controlled entity under section 512(b)(13), in both 2023 and 2024. WIN Minnesota’s 2024 filing reports no related organizations. Alliance for a Better Minnesota names no controlling entity for any of its affiliates.

Graphic: money moved between a chair’s own committees, by year
Money each chair moved into committees they also run, by year. Cardinal’s two biggest years were 2020 and 2022; Williamson’s is this one. Source: Minnesota Campaign Finance Board reports through Oct. 19, 2026, and 24-hour notices through Oct. 23, 2026.

Separately, we found no DFL counterpart to a tax-exempt charity that gave a news site $420,000 and whose board includes this year’s Republican candidate for attorney general. We checked that too. Alliance for a Better Minnesota runs its own 501(c)(3), the Education Fund, at the same St. Paul address as the committee. Its IRS filings report two grants of more than $5,000 from 2020 through 2024: $31,000 to Navigate MN in 2020 and $286,200 to North Star Prosperity, a 501(c)(4), in 2021, both listed as voter education. It reported no grants in 2023 or 2024. Its annual revenue ran between $318,000 and $728,000. It funds no news outlet. One limit: we went through the DFL side’s committee registrations, its receipts and its charity’s grant filings, not every nonprofit in Minnesota politics. Where we looked, we printed what we found.

We pulled that record. First Principles’ Minnesota committee took $2,000,000 from the national PAC in Nashville, not $1 million — four payments of $500,000 each, on Sept. 8, Sept. 10, Sept. 25 and Oct. 6. With the $720,000 from Minnesotans for Justice, that is $2,720,000 in receipts against $2,687,102.26 in independent expenditures — $391,096 backing Ron Schutz and $2,296,006 against Keith Ellison. Minnesota law requires associations giving more than $5,000 to name the underlying source. The committee has one such statement on file, filed with its September report; none is listed with the pre-general report that covers the Sept. 25 and Oct. 6 payments. Whether that requirement reaches a federal political committee is a question for the Board, and we are not saying it was broken.
05 · The candidate’s circle Preview

Follow his record and you keep landing in the same place.

Ron Schutz wants to be Minnesota’s top law enforcement officer. The same place is the Center of the American Experiment, the conservative think tank based in Minnetonka.

The board

Board member, former chair

A CAE director, per its 2025 IRS filing. On his 2025 candidate survey: “the former chair and a current board member” of CAE.

The campaign

CAE’s recordings

The recordings his campaign website cites on fraud are from a December 2021 meeting that KSTP reported CAE first made public, according to KSTP. On Sept. 22, a CAE piece on his race never told readers he sits on its board.

The circle closes

Ron Eibensteiner chairs CAE. He was treasurer of the Minnesota Private Business Council, the group that controls Renew, in 2023 and 2024, according to its IRS filings. He gave Schutz’s campaign $2,500, the legal maximum.

Coming next

The full story on Ron Schutz

This is a preview. Our next piece follows the candidate’s own record, his foundation’s giving and the network around his campaign, in full.

A note on names: Jim Schultz, with an l, ran for attorney general in 2022 and now leads the business council. Ron Schutz, no l, is this year’s candidate.

None of this is illegal. A board member can run for office. A think tank can publish what it likes. But voters deserve to know that the think tank that spotlighted Schutz’s race, the business council behind Renew, and the committees spending for him share people at the top.
Graphic: The candidate’s circle
Schutz has sat on the think tank’s board since 2004, chaired it in 2006–07, and is still a director in its latest IRS filing. His family foundation gave it $91,250; it gave Alpha News $420,000, and Alpha covers his race.
07 · In his own words New

What he said. What the record shows.

Mitchell Williamson posts a lot. We read it so you don’t have to. Every quote is exactly as written. Tap a card to flip it; tap the screenshot to enlarge it.

The template

On Sept. 11, 2025, the day after Charlie Kirk was killed, Williamson posted a thread that drew more than 126,000 views: “Minnesota Democrats have liked, shared, or otherwise promoted some of the most disgusting rhetoric… We’re posting and tagging them all.” He named eight DFL officeholders and a legislator’s campaign manager over things they had posted, reposted or liked, told them, “You should all resign immediately,” and asked followers to find the campaign manager’s employment records. Two days later: “we want people fired for celebrating an assassination.”

A year later, Renew ran the same play on a candidate and a podcast. Comb old posts. Tie the candidate to someone else’s words. Call it political violence.

On Melissa Hortman: the whole record

On June 14, 2025, the day Hortman and her husband were killed, Williamson reposted condolence statements from Republican leaders, and a post rebuking people “clout-chasing” over the death of “an innocent Minnesota lawmaker.” Three months later, when Ryan Winkler wrote that losing Hortman reminded him “how much leadership matters” and that he was considering a run for an open House seat, Williamson replied: “I guess the cannabis business isn’t going too well for him.” On Oct. 1, 2026, Renew’s text attacking Janigo invoked the Hortmans’ assassination.

Williamson reposts condolence statements on June 14, 2025
June 14, 2025: condolence reposts
Williamson reposts a rebuke of clout-chasing, June 14, 2025
June 14, 2025: “clout-chasing” repost
Williamson's reply to Ryan Winkler, Sept. 18, 2025
Sept. 18, 2025: reply to Winkler
Williamson: we want people fired, Sept. 13, 2025
Sept. 13, 2025: “we want people fired”
Graphic: He attacked a senator for outside money
In November he attacked a senator because only 25 percent of his money was local. This year, 74 percent of Renew’s came from one group in Arlington, Virginia.
Graphic: Words he put in other people’s mouths
Statements set in quotation marks that the people quoted never said — a House speaker, a council member, a lieutenant governor.
10 · What the record doesn’t show New

The reports stopped on Oct. 19. The money didn’t.

Everything above comes from public filings. This is what those filings leave out.

Minnesota’s pre-general reports close on Oct. 19. A contribution over $1,000 that arrives after that — in the last two weeks, when the ads run hardest — is disclosed in a separate 24-hour notice instead. Those notices are the only public record of money raised in the final stretch. We pulled every one of them on Oct. 28.

In the eight days after the cutoff, $2,510,500 more came into this network.

Oct. 20, 22 and 23. The Minnesota Private Business Council sent Renew $100,000, then $250,000, then $750,000 — $1,100,000 in four days.

Oct. 22. GOPAC Inc. sent New Fund LLC $1,200,000, about 60 percent of everything New Fund raised in all of 2024.

Oct. 23. The Republican State Leadership Committee sent Advance Minnesota $100,000.

Oct. 27. GOPAC sent Advance Minnesota $110,500, a week before the election.

And on Oct. 21, Renew sent Advance Minnesota $12,000 worth of text messages, reported as an in-kind contribution. It is not the first money to move directly from Renew to the committee that has spent $227,590 against Janigo: Renew gave Advance $22,500 in cash across three payments in 2025, on April 9 and twice on Nov. 20. The Oct. 21 text buy is the first of 2026.

Advance is not funded only from out of state: through the Oct. 19 cutoff GOPAC had given it $1,015,000 and the Republican State Leadership Committee $1,525,000, and Pro Jobs Majority, the Minnesota Chamber of Commerce’s political fund, gave another $850,000. All told, committees have reported spending $1,141,308 against Janigo this year and $117,633 supporting her, led by the DFL State Central Committee at $76,657: nearly ten dollars against her for every one spent on her behalf, counting independent expenditures only and not either campaign’s own spending.

That brings GOPAC’s 2026 total to these three committees to $9,400,500, under three names: “GOPAC Election Fund” to Renew, “GOPAC” to Advance Minnesota, “GOPAC Inc.” to New Fund. The filings don’t say whether those names are one organization or three; they share an Arlington address, and GOPAC Election Fund named GOPAC Inc. as its source on its June and July statements. GOPAC money goes elsewhere in Minnesota too: its federal reports show $980,000 to the Republican Party of Minnesota on Sept. 18.

Graphic: the reports stopped Oct. 19, the money didn't
Every row is a 24-hour notice filed with the Campaign Finance Board.

Which raises the question the filings are supposed to answer: where does GOPAC’s money come from?

When an association gives more than $5,000 in a calendar year to Minnesota independent expenditure committees, state law requires it to tell the recipient committee’s treasurer where the money came from. The form is Schedule A1, “Source of Funding for Contribution.” It asks for every donor of more than $5,000 by name and address, and for one more number: the total attributable to everyone too small to name.

GOPAC Election Fund filled in that schedule in some form five times in 2026 — April, June, July, August and September.

On its two October statements, for $1,200,000 on Oct. 6 and $200,000 on Oct. 16, Schedule A1 is blank. No names. Line A blank, Line B blank, Line C blank. The only entry is the figure on the line that reads “TOTAL AMOUNT OF CONTRIBUTION (Line A + Line B + Line C)” — a sum of three empty boxes. Both were signed by a GOPAC officer. The October 16 statement also leaves the responsible officer’s name, email and phone number blank.

Other donors’ statements filed with the same report were complete. The Minnesota Private Business Council reported $100,000 on Line B — the total from donors too small to itemize, which names no one. GOPAC used Line B the same way in August and September: those forms are filled in, but they name no one either. What makes the two October statements different is that nothing was filled in at all. Common Sense America Election Fund itemized its $150,000 on Line A.

And the five GOPAC did fill in are worth reading. On the April, June and July statements, the only source named is GOPAC Inc. — its own parent organization, at the same Arlington address. The form asks who gave GOPAC the money. GOPAC’s answer was GOPAC.

The biggest spender, and no donors New

The largest spender in the legislative races lists no donors.

$0
reported against 57 DFL candidates in Minnesota, every item dated Sept. 21
0
donors named in any Minnesota or Wisconsin filing

The largest Republican-side spender in this year’s legislative races isn’t one of Williamson’s committees. It is First Amendment LLC, which lists a Fairfax, Va., address. It reported $5,069,835 against 57 DFL candidates, every item dated Sept. 21. It registered with the Campaign Finance Board on Oct. 27 and closed its registration the same day.

57 DFL candidates, one day, $5.07 million
Every item dated Sept. 21. Kristy Janigo drew the fourth-largest amount of the 57.
Formed, spent, registered, closed
Formed Aug. 19. Spent $18 million in September. Registered and closed in Minnesota on Oct. 27.

Its report lists no donors. Neither does its report in Wisconsin, where it spent another $12,993,964 against Democrats the same week. Every dollar in both states went to one vendor, Make Liberty Win LLC, a company formed in Delaware on Aug. 19.

Follow the money: $18 million with no donor on record
Every dollar went to Make Liberty Win LLC. No filing shows where the money came from.
Where the $18 million went
Just over half of it targeted one race, Wisconsin governor.

First Amendment LLC lists the same Virginia office suite and treasurer as Make Liberty Win, a libertarian PAC whose federal account raised $6.85 million over 21 months and spent about $625,000 from July through September. Fox News reported that tech investor Scott Banister contributed $40 million to Make Liberty Win. The Board lists the filer as “First Amendment LLC (Scott Banister)” on the report and the committee page. No filing we found shows where First Amendment LLC’s $18 million came from.

The PAC's own books can't cover it
The federal PAC raised $6.85 million in 21 months. First Amendment LLC spent $18 million in one week.
Minnesota, then and now
In 2024 the same operation spent through a fund with public donor records. In 2026 that fund reported nothing.
Sharing an office suite and a treasurer is not the same as sharing money, and nothing here shows the two groups coordinated. What the filings show is $18,063,799 spent against Democrats in one week, paid to a company formed a month earlier, with no source of funds disclosed in either state.
11 · Why it matters

Nothing here required anyone to break a law. That’s the problem.

A voter in a swing district this fall may hear from Renew Minnesota, Minnesotans for Justice, Empower Minnesota, Build Minnesota and First Principles PAC. Nothing on those ads tells them that one man chairs four of those five committees. Or that three of every four dollars behind the biggest one came from Virginia this year. Or that some of the same donors also fund the Senate Republican caucus’s attacks in the same races. Or that the outlet amplifying the attacks has been funded and written for by people inside the same circle.

When Renew passes money to Empower, Empower’s reports list one donor: Renew Minnesota. The names behind Renew drop off. When Minnesotans for Justice sends money to Nashville, the trail runs through a federal filing most voters will never open.

It doesn’t have to work that way. In 2022, Arizona voters approved a law requiring groups that spend above set thresholds on campaign advertising to name the original sources of that money, even when it passes through middlemen. The law has been challenged in state and federal court and upheld so far.

Until then, it falls to the people willing to read the filings. We’re still reading. We’ll update this site as new filings post.

Renew Minnesota, Mitchell Williamson and Alpha News are welcome to respond to anything here. We’ll add any response.

12 · The whole network on one page

Every connection, in one place.

Tap any box to light up its connections. Pink lines are money, black dashes are people and roles, gold dots are amplification and attack.

Download the full board

Money is pooled at every step: a line shows who funded whom, not that a donor’s dollars paid for a specific ad. Shared donors, officers and vendors are connections, not proof that anyone directed anyone.

Read the investigation →